- Round 1 Match 1: Kate VS Hugo (WINNER: FRECKLES)
- Round 1 Match 2: Miles VS Charlie (WINNER: REJECT FROM VH1'S HAS-BEENS)
- Round 1 Match 3: Charlie, Hurley and Aaron VS Ana Lucia (WINNER: 3 MEN AND A BABY)
- Round 1 Match 4: Richard VS Hugo (WINNER: BUDDY... WITH THE EYELINER)
- Round 1 Match 5: Tom Friendly VS Roger Linus (WINNER: SKELETOR)
- Round 1 Match 6: Jin & Sun VS Jack (WINNER: CROUCHING TIGER & HIDDEN DRAGON)
- Round 1 Match 7: Hugo VS Hugo (WINNER: JUMBOTRON)
- Round 1 Match 8: Man in Black VS Juliet (WINNER: GHOST OF XMAS PAST)
- Round 1 Match 9: Daniel VS Hugo (WINNER: TWITCHY)
- Round 1 Match 10: Ana Lucia VS Mr. Eko (WINNER: SHAFT)
- Round 1 Match 11: Hugo VS Rousseau (WINNER: IHOP)
- Round 2 Match 1: Hugo VS Mr. Eko
- Round 2 Match 2: Danny W VS The Kwons
- Round 2 Match 3: Roger Linus VS Man in Black
- Round 2 Match 4: Richard VS Kate
- Round 2 Match 5: Hugo VS Hugo VS Charlie